Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn

Federal sentencing changed significantly on November 1, 2026, for defendants convicted of multiple counts.

The United States Sentencing Commission adopted Amendment 840 to simplify the rules in Chapter Three, Part D governing multiple counts of conviction. The former framework spread the analysis across U.S.S.G. §§ 3D1.1 through 3D1.5 and required courts to group closely related counts, calculate offense levels for those groups, assign units, and then determine a combined offense level.

The 2026 Guidelines replace that system with a substantially revised U.S.S.G. § 3D1.1.

The purpose remains the same: determine a single offense level that fairly accounts for all counts of conviction without punishing a defendant multiple times for essentially the same conduct.

But the method is different.

For defendants facing multiple federal counts, the new rules can materially affect the advisory Guidelines calculation.

Federal criminal defense attorney Michael J. Petro has more than 35 years of criminal law experience and represents defendants in federal sentencing proceedings in Chicago, Tampa, and federal courts throughout the United States. Multiple-count calculations should be independently reviewed rather than accepted simply because they appear in the Presentence Investigation Report.

The Old Multiple-Count System Has Been Replaced

Before November 1, 2026, Chapter Three, Part D contained five separate guidelines governing multiple counts.

The former system generally required the sentencing court to:

  • Group closely related counts under § 3D1.2;
  • Determine an offense level for each group under § 3D1.3;
  • Assign units to the different groups under § 3D1.4; and
  • Use those units to determine an incremental increase in the combined offense level.

The Sentencing Commission concluded that those rules had become unnecessarily complicated, particularly when courts had to decide whether offenses were related or unrelated and how many units to assign.

Amendment 840 eliminated that multi-step structure.

The 2026 Guidelines now place the principal multiple-count rules in a single provision: § 3D1.1, Procedure for Determining Offense Level on Multiple Counts.

The New § 3D1.1 Uses Different Rules for Different Types of Offenses

The new guideline does not treat every combination of counts the same way.

Instead, § 3D1.1 separates multiple-count cases into several categories.

The first question is therefore not simply how many counts the defendant has.

The court must determine what type of counts are involved and which subsection of § 3D1.1 applies.

Aggregate-Harm Offenses Are Combined

Under § 3D1.1(a), certain offenses are calculated by combining the offense behavior and treating the conduct as a whole.

This approach applies where multiple counts use the same listed guideline and that guideline measures harm primarily through an aggregate quantity or amount.

Important examples include:

  • Fraud under § 2B1.1;
  • Drug trafficking under § 2D1.1;
  • Firearms offenses under § 2K2.1;
  • Money laundering under §§ 2S1.1 and 2S1.3;
  • Tax offenses under Chapter Two, Part T; and
  • Certain bribery and corruption offenses.

For these offenses, the calculation generally focuses on the combined conduct, rather than adding punishment merely because prosecutors charged the conduct in multiple counts.

Example: Multiple Fraud Counts

Assume a defendant is convicted of five wire-fraud counts governed by § 2B1.1.

The counts involve a combined Guidelines loss of $400,000.

The court does not ordinarily calculate five separate loss enhancements merely because the conduct was charged in five counts.

Instead, because § 2B1.1 is one of the guidelines listed in § 3D1.1(a), the offense behavior is considered together and the applicable offense level is determined using the combined conduct.

The formal charging decision should not artificially multiply the punishment for the same aggregate financial harm.

Different Victims or Separate Occasions Can Produce an Incremental Increase

Section 3D1.1(b) addresses a different category of offenses.

For certain listed guidelines, where multiple counts involve different victims or the same victim on different occasions, the court calculates each count separately and then applies an increase based on the number of qualifying counts.

This category includes many offenses involving individualized harm, including:

  • Murder offenses;
  • Assaults;
  • Robberies;
  • Sexual abuse offenses; and
  • Other crimes against separate victims.

Instead of using the former unit system, the 2026 Guidelines use a straightforward count-based table.

The increase is:

Number of qualifying countsIncrease
2 counts+2 levels
3 counts+3 levels
4 or 5 counts+4 levels
6 or more counts+5 levels

The increase is applied to the qualifying count with the highest offense level.

This is one of the most significant changes in Amendment 840.

Example: Three Robberies

Suppose a defendant is convicted of three robbery counts governed by the same listed guideline, each involving a different victim or a separate occasion.

The court first calculates the offense level for each robbery separately.

Assume the offense levels are:

  • Count One: Level 24
  • Count Two: Level 26
  • Count Three: Level 25

Because there are three qualifying counts, § 3D1.1(b) directs the court to add 3 levels to the highest offense level.

The combined offense level for those counts would therefore be based on Level 26 plus 3 levels, resulting in Level 29 before any later applicable adjustments.

The former unit calculation is no longer used.

Remaining Counts Are Calculated Separately

Not every count falls within subsection (a) or subsection (b).

Under § 3D1.1(c), any remaining counts are calculated separately.

The court therefore determines the appropriate offense level for each of those counts under the otherwise applicable Guidelines provisions.

Then § 3D1.1(d) directs the court to identify the highest offense level generated by:

  1. Any group of aggregate-harm counts under subsection (a);
  2. Any group of qualifying multiple-victim or separate-occasion counts under subsection (b); or
  3. Any individual remaining count under subsection (c).

That highest offense level becomes the offense level applicable to all counts before the later Guidelines steps are applied.

Mandatory Consecutive Counts Are Treated Separately

Some federal statutes require a sentence to run consecutively to another sentence.

Those counts are not handled through the ordinary multiple-count calculation.

Section 3D1.1(e) excludes certain mandatory-consecutive counts from subsections (a) through (d).

An important example is 18 U.S.C. § 924(c).

A § 924(c) conviction carries a statutorily required consecutive term of imprisonment. The § 924(c) count is therefore excluded from the ordinary multiple-count calculation and handled under the rules governing consecutive sentences.

Section 3D1.1 also separately addresses convictions under 18 U.S.C. § 1028A, aggravated identity theft.

A defendant’s final sentencing exposure can therefore involve both:

  • An offense level and Guidelines range calculated under § 3D1.1 for the ordinary counts; and
  • A mandatory consecutive sentence required by statute.

That distinction is critical.

The New Rule Does Not Mean the Number of Counts Is Irrelevant

One purpose of the multiple-count rules is to prevent the prosecutor’s charging decision from artificially increasing a defendant’s sentence.

That principle remains part of the 2026 framework.

But it does not mean additional counts never matter.

The consequences depend on the type of offense.

For aggregate-harm crimes such as fraud, drug trafficking, firearms offenses, and certain financial crimes, the Guidelines commonly focus on the combined conduct.

For individualized offenses involving separate victims or separate criminal episodes, additional counts can produce incremental offense-level increases.

The defense therefore needs to identify which rule actually governs before accepting the probation officer’s calculation.

Multiple Drug Counts Under the 2026 Guidelines

Drug cases provide an important example of aggregate-harm sentencing.

Several commonly used drug guidelines, including § 2D1.1, are expressly listed in § 3D1.1(a).

Where multiple counts are governed by the same listed drug guideline, the combined offense conduct is generally considered as a whole.

For example, if a defendant is convicted of multiple cocaine-distribution counts governed by § 2D1.1, the drug quantities attributable to the qualifying counts are considered together for purposes of determining the offense level.

The number of counts does not ordinarily create a separate incremental increase merely because the government divided the distribution conduct into multiple charges.

The critical disputes may instead concern:

  • Drug quantity;
  • Relevant conduct;
  • Whether quantities were reasonably foreseeable;
  • Whether particular transactions should be attributed to the defendant;
  • Purity;
  • Drug type; and
  • Applicable specific offense characteristics.

Multiple Fraud Counts Under the 2026 Guidelines

Fraud cases work similarly because § 2B1.1 is listed under § 3D1.1(a).

When multiple fraud counts use § 2B1.1, the Guidelines generally calculate the offense level based on the combined offense behavior.

Important issues can include:

  • Actual loss;
  • Intended loss;
  • Number of victims;
  • Sophisticated means;
  • Financial hardship;
  • Securities or commodities conduct;
  • Government benefits;
  • Credits against loss; and
  • Relevant conduct.

The defense should not assume that the indictment’s count structure determines the Guidelines result.

The economic conduct underlying the counts often matters far more than the raw number of counts.

Multiple Firearms Counts

Section 2K2.1 is also included in § 3D1.1(a).

Accordingly, multiple qualifying firearms counts governed by § 2K2.1 are generally determined by considering the combined offense behavior as a whole.

The calculation may therefore depend on factors such as:

  • Number of firearms;
  • Type of firearm;
  • Whether a firearm was stolen;
  • Whether a serial number was altered or obliterated;
  • Whether the defendant possessed the firearm in connection with another felony offense; and
  • The defendant’s criminal history or prohibited status.

Again, the number of counts alone does not necessarily determine the offense level.

Relevant Conduct Still Matters

The revised multiple-count rules did not eliminate the Guidelines’ relevant-conduct provisions.

A defendant can therefore face an offense level based on conduct broader than the precise conduct charged in an individual count.

The court may still need to determine what conduct qualifies as relevant under § 1B1.3 before applying the appropriate Chapter Two guideline and the new multiple-count rules.

This is particularly important in:

  • Conspiracy cases;
  • Drug prosecutions;
  • Fraud schemes;
  • Money laundering cases; and
  • Jointly undertaken criminal activity.

The defense must distinguish between the counts of conviction and the conduct legally attributable to the defendant under the Guidelines.

The Correct Guidelines Manual Must Be Determined First

The new multiple-count rules took effect November 1, 2026.

That does not mean the 2026 Manual can automatically be used in every case.

U.S.S.G. § 1B1.11 generally directs the sentencing court to use the Guidelines Manual in effect on the date of sentencing.

But if use of the current Manual would produce a harsher Guidelines range and create an ex post facto problem, the court may be required to use the earlier Manual.

This issue is particularly important during the transition to the 2026 Guidelines because the methodology for multiple counts has materially changed.

A defendant sentenced after November 1, 2026 may therefore require a comparison between the 2026 calculation and the calculation under the Guidelines in effect at the time of the offense.

The correct Manual should be determined before the court calculates the advisory sentencing range.

The Presentence Report Should Be Independently Checked

The probation officer will ordinarily perform the multiple-count analysis in the Presentence Investigation Report.

That calculation should not be accepted without review.

Defense counsel should ask:

  • Is each count governed by the correct Chapter Two guideline?
  • Does § 3D1.1(a), (b), or (c) apply?
  • Are all counts placed in the proper category?
  • Are the counts actually governed by the same guideline?
  • Do subsection (b) counts involve different victims or separate occasions?
  • Is the correct number-of-counts enhancement being used?
  • Has a mandatory-consecutive count been improperly included?
  • Has relevant conduct been attributed correctly?
  • Is the correct Guidelines Manual being applied?

An error at this stage can affect the total offense level and potentially change the advisory imprisonment range.

The 2026 Rules Are Simpler—but They Still Require Careful Analysis

The Sentencing Commission intended Amendment 840 to simplify multiple-count sentencing.

It eliminated the former unit system and consolidated five guidelines into one principal provision.

That does not make multiple-count sentencing automatic.

The court must still classify the counts correctly, calculate the applicable Chapter Two offense levels, determine whether conduct should be combined, identify separate victims and occasions, address relevant conduct, remove mandatory-consecutive counts from the ordinary calculation, and determine which Guidelines Manual legally applies.

Those decisions can materially affect a defendant’s sentence.

Federal sentencing is not a mechanical exercise. When a defendant faces multiple counts, the calculation under the 2026 Guidelines should be independently reconstructed and challenged when the Presentence Investigation Report overstates the applicable offense level.

Michael J. Petro represents defendants in federal criminal cases and federal sentencing proceedings in Chicago, Tampa, and throughout the United States.