Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn

A federal criminal defendant has a constitutional right to a fair and impartial jury. When a juror receives an outside communication, conducts independent research, or is exposed to information not admitted at trial, the court may be required to investigate whether the outside influence affected the verdict.

Not every allegation of juror misconduct creates a presumption of prejudice. The legal analysis depends heavily on whether the alleged misconduct involved an external influence or occurred entirely within the jury’s deliberations.

If outside information, an unauthorized communication, or pressure on a juror may have affected your federal trial, contact federal criminal defense attorney Michael J. Petro immediately. The issue may support a mistrial, a new trial, or reversal on appeal.

External Influence on a Federal Jury

An external influence comes from a source outside the jury and introduces information, pressure, or communication that was not presented through the courtroom process.

Examples may include:

• A communication from a witness, party, court employee, family member, or other outsider

• News reports about the defendant or trial

• Independent internet research

• Social media communications

• Visiting a relevant location without authorization

• Consulting outside reference materials

• Receiving threats, pressure, or attempted bribes

• Learning about excluded evidence or the defendant’s criminal history

• Discussing the case with someone who is not a juror

External influence is especially serious because it exposes jurors to information that was not admitted into evidence and could not be tested through objections, cross-examination, or judicial instructions.

Internal Juror Misconduct

Internal misconduct generally involves conduct occurring among jurors during deliberations.

Examples may include:

• Jurors discussing the evidence among themselves

• A juror misunderstanding an instruction

• A juror relying on personal experience

• Arguments or pressure among jurors

• A juror changing a vote

• Statements made during deliberations

Internal misconduct does not ordinarily trigger the same presumption that may arise from an outside influence. Courts also face significant restrictions on their ability to investigate the substance of jury deliberations.

The distinction between internal and external misconduct can determine whether the court may question jurors and what evidence it may consider.

The Remmer Presumption of Prejudice

In Remmer v. United States, 347 U.S. 227 (1954), the Supreme Court addressed an unauthorized communication with a juror concerning a matter pending before the jury.

When the defendant makes a sufficient showing that an unauthorized external contact occurred and related to the case, the contact may be presumed prejudicial. The presumption is not conclusive. The government may attempt to establish that the contact was harmless.

The precise application of the Remmer presumption can vary among federal circuits and depends on the nature of the contact. A speculative allegation is generally not enough. The defense should identify credible evidence of an unauthorized communication or outside influence.

The Court’s Duty to Investigate

When a credible allegation of external influence arises, the trial judge must conduct an inquiry sufficient to determine what happened and whether the defendant was prejudiced.

The appropriate investigation depends on the circumstances. It may include:

• Questioning the affected juror

• Separately questioning other jurors

• Identifying the source of the communication

• Determining when the contact occurred

• Examining what information was communicated

• Determining whether the information reached other jurors

• Considering whether the contact concerned guilt, punishment, or another central issue

• Allowing counsel to propose questions or participate in the hearing

Individual questioning is not automatically required in every case. However, a general instruction may be inadequate when the source, extent, and effect of the improper communication remain unknown.

Limits on Questioning Jurors

Federal Rule of Evidence 606(b) generally prevents jurors from testifying about statements made during deliberations, the effect of anything on a juror’s vote, or the juror’s mental processes.

The rule permits limited inquiry into whether:

• Extraneous prejudicial information was improperly brought to the jury’s attention

• An outside influence was improperly brought to bear on a juror

• A mistake was made in entering the verdict on the verdict form

The court may investigate the existence and nature of an outside influence without conducting an unrestricted examination of the jurors’ mental processes or deliberations.

Defense counsel must frame the inquiry carefully to establish improper external contact while complying with Rule 606(b).

United States v. Vasquez Ruiz

In United States v. Vasquez Ruiz, 502 F.3d 700 (7th Cir. 2007), the defendant was tried on federal mail fraud and health care fraud charges.

Nine days into the trial, a juror reported that someone had written the word “GUILTY” in her trial notebook. The message appeared before deliberations and intimidated the juror.

The source of the message was unknown. Another juror may have written it, but an outsider with access to the notebook was also a possibility.

The district court questioned the affected juror, compared handwriting samples, and gave the jury a cautionary instruction. It did not determine who wrote the message or question the remaining jurors individually. The court denied the defendant’s motion for a mistrial.

Why the Seventh Circuit Reversed

The Seventh Circuit concluded that the record did not contain enough information to determine the source and effect of the message.

If an outsider wrote the message, the Remmer presumption applied, and the government could not rebut that presumption without developing the relevant facts. If another juror wrote it, the message still suggested that a juror may have prejudged the case and attempted to pressure another juror before deliberations began.

The message went directly to the ultimate question of guilt. Because the source was never identified and the record remained inadequate, the Court of Appeals concluded that a general curative instruction was insufficient.

The court reversed the judgment and remanded the case for further proceedings.

The Seventh Circuit’s complete opinion in United States v. Vasquez Ruiz demonstrates why a court must develop an adequate record before deciding that an apparent attempt to influence a juror was harmless.

Possible Remedies for Juror Misconduct

The appropriate remedy depends on when the problem is discovered, the nature of the misconduct, and whether the court can protect the defendant’s right to an impartial jury.

Possible remedies include:

• A focused curative instruction

• Individual questioning of jurors

• Removal and replacement of an affected juror

• A mistrial

• A posttrial evidentiary hearing

• A new trial

• Reversal on appeal

A curative instruction may be sufficient when the facts are known, and the risk can be contained. A mistrial may be necessary when the source or extent of the influence cannot be determined or when the misconduct concerns the defendant’s guilt.

Preserving a Juror Misconduct Claim

Defense counsel should bring a credible allegation to the court’s attention immediately and request an adequate investigation. The record should identify the suspected outside influence, explain its potential effect on the jury, and describe why a general instruction would not cure the problem.

Counsel should also request appropriate findings and preserve objections to the court’s investigative procedure and chosen remedy.

Attorney Michael J. Petro represents individuals in federal criminal trials and appeals in Tampa, Florida, and Chicago, Illinois. Contact federal criminal defense attorney Michael J. Petro today if juror misconduct or outside influence may have affected your federal criminal case.